Posted on by mtompkins

Bodies

There are many stances on the controversial topic of abortion in our society. Arguably the most prominent stances are the often conservative associated pro-life stance and the feminist/liberal stance of pro-choice. Ronnie Zoe Hawkins discusses an ecofeminist stance to abortion that not only involves the reflections of feminist thinking of abortion, as well as how the environment should play a role in people’s stances on abortion. Through Hawkins’s stance, she sees abortion as a means to control the population and environmental degradation, how this issue disproportionately impacts women in poverty. I am personally pro-choice myself and I agree with Hawkins’s views on ecofeminist reasonings surrounding abortion. 

After reading Hawkins’s views on abortion being a form of population control, I realized that this was a matter that I had not thought too much into. Hawkins identifies the population growth that has been experienced in the last two centuries from around 1 billion to 5-6 billion as of 1993 (Hawkins 690). According to the Worldometer, our current population is nearing 8 billion people. The growing population should be a legitimate concern to our environment due to the fact that there is a finite amount of resources that can be used to supply the human population. Thinking in Hawkins’s ecofeminist perspective, abortion is a viable means of population control because imagining a world where no abortions are performed makes me think like our world would be entirely overpopulated and resources would be depleted more so than ever. Allowing for women to terminate pregnancies allows for less resources to be depleted at a slower rate than if our population were to be higher from more births. 

Another crucial point surrounding the usage of the planet’s resources for the growing human population is the fact that other non-human organisms would be greatly impacted as well. Hawkins states that a growing population leads to more resources being produced and consumed, meaning that environments and habitats of non-human organisms can be destroyed (Hawkins 691). “…Anthropogenic, or human-caused, species extinctions are occurring at several hundred times the “natural” rate and, since they are the result of abrupt and often total destruction of habitats, are not offset by new speciation (Hawkins 691).” A feminist view of abortion neglects the impacts that abortion may have, whether positive or negative, on non-human organisms. By using an ecofeminist lens allows for it to become more clear that the population control aspect of abortion also leads to benefitting the world’s natural resources and the species of non-human organisms that would be displaced or harmed in the harvesting of the resources needed for the births that could potentially take place.

On a personal note, the looming threat of climate change is one factor that aids my agreement with Hawkins. I would not want to raise a child in the environment that we are potentially headed towards. If serious changes are not made in order to save the planet, we may be facing irreversible environmental damage in a matter of years. I personally would not want to bring even more human lives into the world that would have to live with these irreversible issues that were caused before their time where we would also not be able to sustain such a large population with the amount of resources available.

Lastly, the link that poverty plays in Hawkins analysis of abortion puts into perspective that abortion can sometimes be the most viable method for pregnant women in developing nations to terminate pregnancies. In an op-ed by one of the International Planned Parenthood Federation’s directors, Carmen Barroso, she provides that in 2015 over 200 million women went without access to modern contraceptive methods (Barroso 1). Contraception is not widely accepted or available to women, most prominently women in developing nations, leaving abortion as a common option for these women.

In terms of ecofeminist values, I personally believe that Hawkins’s views encompass what environmentalism and feminism stand for. Hawkins acknowledges that some more traditional ecofeminists see abortion as a “masculine” response to unwanted pregnancies and does not allow for respect of the natural process of gestation and birth to take place (Hawkins 693). As stated, feminist views do not encompass impacts faced by both human and non-human beings, and solely focuses on the rights aspect of human women having free will and agency of their bodies, or the disagreement with this belief. I believe that an ecofeminist perspective on abortion can be beneficial when one can take into the consideration the environmental benefits that abortion has had in terms of Hawkins’s writings. 

Sources:

Barroso, Carmen. “Empower Women for the Health of the Planet.” The New York Times, 8 June 2015, https://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2015/06/08/is-overpopulation-a-legitimate-threat-to-humanity-and-the-planet/empower-women-for-the-health-of-the-planet

Bess, Gabby. “Reuse, Reduce, Reproductive Rights: How Abortion Can Help Save the Planet.” Vice, 6 Oct. 2015, www.vice.com/en_us/article/vv5kj9/reuse-reduce-reproductive-rights-how-abortion-can-help-save-the-planet.

This article from Vice provided an interview from a member of PAI, a global organization that promotes women’s reproductive health, to discuss how a woman’s right to choose can benefit the environment. Allison Doody reinforces in her responses how abortion as a woman’s right can impact sustainability of natural resources, how the United Nations has placed policies into action that benefit both reproductive rights and the environment, as well as statistics surrounding abortin and other reproductive processes. This source provided another ecofeminist perspective that contributed to the ideas shared by Ronnie Hawkins to further the understanding of ecofeminism and abortion.

Hawkins, Ronnie Zoe. “Reproductive Choices: The Ecological Dimension.” Living With Contradictions: Controversies in Feminist Social Ethics, 1993, pp 690-694.

482 Replies to “Bodies”

  45. It’s impressive that you are getting ideas from this paragraph as well as from our
    dialogue made at this place.

    Reply

  46. hello there and thank you for your information – I’ve certainly picked up something new from right here.
    I did however expertise a few technical issues using this
    web site, as I experienced to reload the website many times previous to I could get it to load properly.

    I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK?
    Not that I am complaining, but slow loading instances times
    will very frequently affect your placement in google and could damage your quality score
    if ads and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my email and can look out for a lot
    more of your respective interesting content. Make sure you update this again soon.

    Reply

  47. Personalized support fгom OMT’s skilled tutors helps
    students ɡet over mathematics obstacles, fostering а heartfelt connection to the subject and motivation for exams.

    Dive intο ѕelf-paced mathematics mastery ѡith OMT’s 12-month e-learning courses, tⲟtɑl with practice worksheets аnd tape-recorded sessions f᧐r thorough modification.

    Ιn a syѕtеm whеrе math education һɑѕ developed tо cultivate innovation and
    global competitiveness, registering іn math tuition ensures trainees гemain ahead bү
    deepening theiг understanding аnd application οf key principles.

    Math tuition addresses specific discovering speeds,
    enabling primary trainees tο deepen understanding of PSLE topics lіke location, border, ɑnd volume.

    Secondary math tuition lays ɑ strong groundwork for post-O Level studies, such
    ɑs A Levels ߋr polytechnic courses, Ƅy standing ߋut in foundational
    topics.

    Customized junior college tuition helps link tһe gap from
    O Level to Ꭺ Level math, guaranteeing students adapt to the enhanced roughness
    and deepness required.

    Distinctively, OMT enhances tһe MOE educational program ԝith ɑ proprietary program that incⅼudes real-tіmе progression monitoring fօr customized renovation plans.

    Adaptable scheduling suggests no clashing ԝith
    CCAs οne, maҝing sure well balanced life and climbing mathematics scores.

    Math tuition accommodates varied knowing designs,
    ensuring no Singapore student іs left in thе race fⲟr exam
    success.

    Hеre is my web-site … math tuition jc

    Reply

Leave a Reply to https://applebtcs.com/ Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *